Best Villain Character
This character has been voted by the community to be remembered as the one who lied, cheated, and stole better than anyone else in any fanon.
Heather Villegas
Heather Villegas
Contestant Profile
Birth Date May 12, 1986 (1986-05-12) (age 32)
Hometown Atlanta, GA
Occupation Boarding School Instructor

Survivor: Caucasus

Tribes Rioni
Placement 6/20
Challenges Won 9
Votes Against 15
Days Lasted 36

Heather Villegas is a contestant on Survivor: Caucasus.


Being raised in the prim and proper environment of her boarding school during her childhood, 26 year old Heather Villegas from Atlanta, Georgia works as an Instructor at the very same school she went to. But despite being surrounded by this, Heather developed a spiteful and superficial personality. However, she claims that this gives her the cut-throat attitude that is needed in progressing farther in the game and that she is not afraid of cutting off ties with anyone.

Survivor: Caucasus

Upon arriving to her assigned Rioni camp, Heather immediately alienated herself from her tribe. She quickly made enemies with fellow tribemate Hazel Quezada who later plotted to get her eliminated. Fortunately for her, she would later team up with Aaron McCarthy and Winston Grant and the three of them would eventually take control of the fake Hidden Immunity Idols hidden around camp.

Looks like the clues for the idols are hidden in the rewards we win from the challenges. This means that if we keep winning reward challenges and Aaron, Winston, or I take the clues that are hidden in the rewards, we'll be the only ones in the whole game that know about the fake idols. This will come in handy at some point.


Heather was safe at her tribe's first Tribal Council as her tribe unanimously decided to send home Max Fisher, but she would then be a prime target after her tribe was sent to Tribal for a second time. Luckily, after giving swing vote Agatha Christenson a fake idol, pretending it was the real deal, her alliance managed to send her enemy, Hazel home.

After her tribe came back from Tribal, she and Aaron shared an intimate kiss and slept together that night. However, she then stated that what happened between the two of them was just a one time thing.

To make things clear, Aaron and I did not have sex. We just got caught up in the moment and it's something that definitely won't happen again. Besides, I need to get my head focused in the game.


After learning that both tribes would go to Tribal Council on Day 14, Heather's alliance seemed to be in control of the Rioni tribe. However, her alliance was still unable to find the tribe's real Hidden Immunity Idol. Thinking that the alliance of Yessica Chang, Gerardo Guzman, and Rachel Hudson already found it, her alliance decided to split the votes between Gerardo and Rachel. However this backfired on them as Agatha and Martin Bowell weren't told of the plan and flipped sides during the revote, sending Winston home.

Voting History

Heather's Voting History
Voted Against
1 Rioni Tribe Immune
2 Max Max
3 Hazel Hazel, Gerardo,
Yessica, Rachel
4 Rioni Tribe Immune
5 Gerardo;
6 Rachel Samantha, Amy, Lauren,
Yessica, Agatha, Rachel
7 Rioni Tribe Immune
8 Rioni Tribe Immune
9 Samantha -
10 Samantha Individual Immunity
11 No Tribal Council
Derek -
12 Yessica -
13 Agatha Yessica, Amy,
Daniel, Agatha
Voted Out, Day 36
Voted for
Sole Survivor

^1 In She Can't Blame It On The Alcohol, the vote ended with a 3-3 tie between Gerardo and Winston, forcing a revote, where the only eligible for elimination were Gerardo and Winston. At the revote, Heather still voted for Gerardo.


Shortly after Survivor: Caucasus, she began dating fellow castaway, Aaron McCarthy.



  • Heather bears an uncanny resemblance to Harry Potter character, Ginevra Weasley.
  • Heather's Luxury Item was Butterfly Net.
  • Heather won the Best Villain Character award at the 1st Survivor Fanon Awards Ceremony in 2014.
Survivor: Caucasus Contestants

Aaron McCarthy · Agatha Christenson · Amy Corazon · Daniel Marvin · Derek Phu · Gerardo Guzman · Hazel Quezada · Heather Villegas · Lauren Faas · Martin Bowell · Mary-Jean Pettie · Max Fisher · Phoebe Noyola · Rachel Hudson · Samantha Marino · Sebastian Hibbard · Stan Bailey · Van Stevenson · Winston Grant · Yessica Chang