Due to Node Count issues, this page is a continuation from I'm the Boogeyman, the 90 minute premiere episode of Survivor: Tasmania - Vengeance
Pyengana Tribal Council[]
The footage turns to show the members of the Pyengana tribe arriving at tribal council through the darkness. As they enter the hut, Jeff Probst is shown standing there as he waits for them. Once all 10 castaways are inside, Jeff addresses them.
Jeff Probst: Behind each of you is a torch, grab one and approach the flame. Dip it in and get fire.
Each member of the Pyengana tribe does as Jeff instructs as he continues with his traditional opening statement.
Jeff Probst: As always in this game, fire represents your life. As long as you have fire, you're still in the game. Once your fire is gone, so are you. That will be the case for one of you tonight.
Jeff as well as the members of Pyengana all sit down on their respective stools.
Jeff Probst: Welcome to tribal council. Although this is not a place you want to be because one of you will become the first member of the Vengeance tribe. Lamont, what's the feeling when you guys win the challenge, but you still have to come here?
Lamont: Oh there's definite mixed feelings for sure, Jeff. I mean, we're all happy that we won without a doubt! I mean, not only do we have flint, but we won PIZZA! The downside obviously though is that while we won that challenge as a tribe, one person won't get to enjoy that part of the reward, even though they fought for it.
The entire tribe nods in agreement with Lamont's statement as Jeff continues.
Jeff Probst: Let's talk about the main twist in play this season... Vengeance. Libby, as a self-professed fan of this show, how does strategy change knowing that not only may the person you guys vote out tonight be coming back, but also that they will be competing AGAINST you in all future challenges and if they win, they have a say in which tribe goes to tribal.
Libby: The Vengeance twist certainly has to be weighing on the minds of every single person here tonight. As far as conversations that I've been involved in, the slight possibility of sending someone weak to the Vengeance tribe for the sole purpose of us winning future challenges has been brought up. Whether or not that actually happens tonight though, we'll have to wait and see.
Jeff Probst: Sheila, just by looking at you and a couple others in particular, it's safe to say that based on appearances you can be branded as weak. Does that worry you at all?
Sheila (Shaking her head): Jeff, I'd be lying to you if I said it didn't worry me. I just hope that the social relationships that I've built with these people as well as the fact I work my ass off at camp is enough to get me through this vote.
Jeff Probst: Jocelyn, is there a difference between strength at camp and at challenges? If so, is one necessarily more important?
Jocelyn: You definitely have to consider both Jeff since this isn't Big Brother. You know, where they have all the comforts of home. We have to work to survive in these conditions. As Libby said though, challenge strength has to play a part in is because we don't want Vengeance sending us here day after day.
Jeff Probst: Let's talk about camp life. Yoshi, does this tribe get along overall?
Yoshi: I'm not going to lie, Jeff. There are definitely personalities here that clash quite hard. Those people in particular would be William who clashes with Cameron and Tamara.
Jeff Probst: William, what is it about Cameron and Tamara that you don't like?
William: Honestly Jeff, I think those kids have a lot of growing up to do. I don't think they take themselves, or life for that matter, seriously at all. One of these days, they're gonna get a reality check and it's gonna slap them hard in the face.
As William is speaking, Sheila, Cameron, and Tamara are all shown to have disgusted looks on their faces with Tamara in particular rolling her eyes and shaking her head.
Jeff Probst: Tamara, a lot of reaction from you on that!
Tamara: Jeff, I just find William to be extremely superficial. Cameron and I have done nothing to offend him other than dying our hair and getting tattoos!
William (Interrupting): TAMARA! You and Cameron do NOTHING for the tribe! I work my ass off day in and day out, and you especially do f*** all!
Tamara (Offended): What the Hell are you talking about?! I contribute to our survival here just as much as anyone else! As does Cameron! You've done nothing but belittle Cameron and I since day one and I'm sorry, but it seems like you're just fishing for some sort of half-decent excuse to not like us!
William: You can say what you want, it doesn't change facts!
Tamara: Yeah, and the facts are that you're a f***ing ass****!!
As Tamara and William continue to argue, Cameron just sits quietly biting his lip nervously. After a little while, Jeff addresses Cameron.
Jeff Probst: Cameron, you're name was brought up quite a bit during that exchange. Do you have anything to add?
Cameron: Not really, Jeff. I think Tamara pretty much said everything that I was thinking. It just frustrates me because I've been judged by people like William my entire life for just being different, and now it's happening again after he forms this entire opinion with only one look at me!
Jeff Probst: Molly, we know that the Vengeance twist has played a big part in the discussion as to who to vote out; but, how does this clash between William, Tamara, and Cameron weigh in on top of that?
Molly: It's definitely clear that conflict within a tribe can bring it down big time. A lot of these challenges rely on teamwork, so it's crucial that conflicts at camp be resolved quickly. Now I can't say if any of those three will go home tonight with any certainty, I just know that it's been brought up that their conflict should be dealt with.
Jeff Probst: Alright, well it's certainly been an interesting first tribal council to say the least. I personally have no idea who will be the first member of the Vengeance tribe. But it is time to vote. Yoshi, you're up.
Yoshi heads up to the voting booth and casts his vote, which is not shown. Sheila and Jocelyn are the next two to vote with their votes not being revealed either.
William is the next person to vote. His vote for Tamara is revealed to the public.
| “ | Tamara, you do NOTHING for this tribe. I will not let a girl obsessed with purple and possibly influenced by Satan run this game. Good bye and good riddance! | ” |
–William | ||
Molly is the next person to cast a vote, followed by Lamont, Phoenix, and Cameron in that order. None of their votes are revealed.
Tamara is the next person to vote. Her vote for William is revealed and we can see that she has written "Willy Wonka" on the parchment in big bold letters.
| “ | I am sick and tired of your judgmental ass Willy Wonka! Honestly, I don't give a s*** if you like that nickname or not because clearly you don't give enough of a s*** to get to know Cameron and I before placing unfair judgement on us. Since it's clearly you or me tonight, good bye Willy Wonka, I wish you all the worst! | ” |
–Tamara | ||
Libby is the final person to cast a vote. We are only shown Libby placing her folded up vote in the urn before she sits back down with the rest of her tribe. Once she sits back down, Jeff Probst addresses the tribe.
Jeff Probst: I'll go tally the votes.
Jeff leaves to fetch the urn. When he returns, he addresses the castaways.
Jeff Probst: If anybody has a Hidden Immunity Idol and would like to play it, now would be the time to do so.
Sheila, Cameron, and Tamara look in William's direction and William looks squarely at Tamara. When nobody moves to play an idol, Jeff continues.
Jeff Probst: Okay. Once the votes are read, the decision is final. Person voted out will be asked to leave the tribal council area immediately. I'll read the votes.
Jeff opens up the urn and takes out the first vote.
Jeff Probst: First vote... "Willy Wonka"...
William shoots Tamara a disgusted look as Tamara smirks.
... Tamara...
1 vote William, 1 vote Tamara...
... William...
... William...
That's 3 votes William, 1 vote Tamara...
... Tamara...
... William...
That's 4 votes William, 2 votes Tamara...
... Tamara...
... Tamara...
4 votes William, 4 votes Tamara...
... Tamara...
That's 5 votes Tamara, 4 votes William, 1 vote left...
First person voted out of Survivor: Tasmania- Vengeance...
... Tamara.
Jeff Probst: Tamara, you need to bring me your torch.
Tamara smiles and nods as she accepts her fate as #Blindside appears in the bottom left side of the screen. Cameron's jaw drops and Libby is shown smirking. After Tamara grabs her bag, she shares big hugs with Sheila, Lamont, Molly, and ending with Cameron. Tamara then takes her torch and places it in the holder in front of Jeff Probst.
Jeff Probst: Tamara, the tribe has spoken.
Jeff then places the snuffer on top of Tamara's torch. As he takes it off, smoke can be seen coming out of Tamara's torch where her flame once was.
Jeff Probst: You will have a chance to get back in the game. Grab your torch, and head over to the Vengeance camp.
Tamara thanks Jeff before turning to her former tribe mates.
Tamara: Good luck guys. William, I never thought I'd say this, but I hope to see you soon.
William just glares at Tamara as she takes her torch, leaves the tribal council area and heads off into the night.
Jeff Probst: Well, this was clearly a very emotional and explosive first tribal council. We've seen in the past that this kind of conflict is only detrimental to a tribe in the long run. I hope for your sake, that this vote helps resolve that conflict. Alright, now it's time to get to the reward, take your torches and head over to the jury bench where you will be served pizza as you listen in on Hobart's tribal council.
| Tribal Council 1: Pyengana | |
|---|---|
| Voted Against |
Voter |
 Tamara (6 votes) |
      Jocelyn, Lamont, Libby, Phoenix, William & Yoshi |
Willam (4 votes) |
   Cameron, Molly, Sheila, Tamara |
| VOTED OFF: Tamara Oakenwald | |
Hobart Tribal Council[]
As the Pyengana tribe moves over to the jury benches, the Hobart tribe is shown entering the tribal council hut through the darkness. Once all ten Hobart members have arrived, Jeff begins his traditional opening statement.
Jeff Probst: Behind each of you is a torch, grab one and approach the flame. Dip it in and get fire.
Each member of the Hobart tribe now does as Jeff instructs as he continues with his speech. As they are doing this, the Pyengana tribe is being served their pizza. Many different kinds of pizza are put in front of them from thick crust to thin crust with toppings ranging from cheese or pepperoni to Hawaiian to Canadian to Super Deluxe. The tribe is also served cola to wash the pizza down.
Jeff Probst: As always in this game, fire represents your life. As long as you have fire, you're still in the game. Once your fire is gone, so are you. That will be the case for one of you tonight.
Jeff as well as the members of Hobart all sit down on their respective stools.
Jeff Probst: If you guys take a look at the jury area, you will get your first look at the new Pyengana tribe. Tamara voted out at the first tribal council and she became the first member of the Vengeance tribe.
The members of the Hobart tribe look over at the Pyengana tribe and see that the purple-haired girl missing. They also see the enormous amount of pizza that has been served and Pyengana receives a few jealous stares as a result.
Jeff Probst: Fraser, how frustrating is it to not only lose the first challenge, but to also have your rival tribe consuming their reward before your very eyes?
Fraser: You have no idea how frustrating it is, Mr. Jeffrey Probst! Quite honestly, I find it real f***ing embarrassing, especially when you have the f***ing LEAD going into the puzzle and you STILL lose!
Jeff Probst: Inge, Fraser makes a good point. You guys had a huge lead going into the puzzle portion of the challenge, and you guys were not able to figure it out. As one of the people on the puzzle in that challenge, does it worry you that your tribe may use that against you?
Inge: Of course it does, Jeff! However, I wasn't the only one on the puzzle, so i can't solely be blamed for costing us the challenge.
Jeff Probst: Megan, you were also one of the people that blew it on the puzzle. Same question I gave Inge, are you worried that it may come back to haunt you at this vote?
Megan: I'd be lying to you if I said that it never once crossed my mind, but as Inge said, there were multiple people on that puzzle and I alone can't be blamed for our loss.
Jeff Probst: K.C., with multiple people on the puzzle in the challenge, how does the tribe make a decision as to who to vote out?
K.C.: I think camp life has to come into play as well. I mean, there are people here that clearly do more work around camp than others. If people don't have a strong work ethic at camp, we're going to grow weak eventually and possibly be at the mercy of either the people pigging out over there (points to the Pyengana tribe) or even worse, Vengeance!
Hershey is shown rolling her eyes throughout K.C.'s statement.
Jeff Probst: Hershey, you're clearly not impressed with that response.
Hershey: Obviously, Officer Newman is referring to me when he says that. (Raising her voice as she points to K.C.) That's right Pyengana, OFFICER Newman!
The eyes of the Pyengana tribe members widen at Hershey's revelation as K.C. rolls his eyes and shakes his head.
Jeff Probst: K.C., she just let the entire Pyengana tribe know you're a cop.
K.C.: If I really gave a rat's ass about people knowing I'm a cop, I wouldn't let people know that information in the first place, let alone Hershey.
Jeff Probst: Aren't you worried that it might put a target on your back in the future?
K.C.: In this game, Jeff, people will look for any excuse in the book to target you. Even if it's something as simple/stupid as wiping your ass with two leaves instead of one.
K.C.'s comment sparks laughter from everyone except himself, mostly because of the dead serious look on his face.
Jeff Probst: Kelly, how worried are you tonight that you might join Tamara on Vengeance?
Kelly: I'm definitely worried Jeff, no question about it. Especially since I in particular didn't have a stellar performance in the challenge. I just hope that these people see what I've contributed to our life at camp to keep this group as a whole strong compared to... certain other people.
Hershey is shown rolling her eyes as Jeff addresses the Pyengana tribe.
Jeff Probst: And with that, it is time to get to the vote. Pyengana, drop what's in your hands and finish what's in your mouth. Grab your torches, and head back to camp. I'll see you tomorrow.
The Pyengana tribe does as Jeff instructs. Once Pyengana is gone, Jeff turns back to Hobart.
Jeff Probst: Alright, it is time to vote. Gail, you're up.
Gail stands and makes her way to the voting booth. Once there however, she is simply shown taking the cap off of the pen before the camera fades out.
Vicktor, Percy, Megan, and Fraser are the next people to vote in that order, none of their votes are revealed.
Kelly is the next person to cast a vote. His vote for Hershey is revealed to the public.
| “ | Out here you've proven to be nothing but a lazy, annoying, horny little girl. You're "Best Before Date" is clearly long gone and so I hope it's you tonight and not me. | ” |
–Kelly | ||
Hershey is the next person to vote. Her vote for Kelly is revealed to the public.
| “ | Never underestimate someone as sweet as Hershey's chocolate. | ” |
–Hershey | ||
Selina is the next castaway to vote, followed by Inge. K.C. is the last person to cast a vote. He is simply shown closing up the urn with his vote inside as he makes his way back to join his tribe. Once K.C. sits down, Jeff Probst addresses the Hobart tribe.
Jeff Probst: I'll go tally the votes.
Jeff leaves to fetch the urn. When he returns, he addresses the castaways.
Jeff Probst: If anybody has a Hidden Immunity Idol and would like to play it, now would be the time to do so.
Kelly and Hershey are both shown just staring straight at Jeff. Seeing that nobody is playing an idol, Jeff continues.
Jeff Probst: Okay. Once the votes are read, the decision is final. Person voted out will be asked to leave the tribal council area immediately. I'll read the votes.
Jeff opens up the urn and takes out the first vote.
Jeff Probst: First vote... Hershey...
... Kelly...
1 vote Hershey, 1 vote Kelly...
... Kelly...
... Hershey...
That's 2 votes Kelly, 2 votes Hershey...
... Kelly...
... Kelly...
That's 4 votes Kelly, 2 votes Hershey...
... Kelly...
That's 5 votes Kelly, 2 votes Hershey...
Second person voted out of Survivor: Tasmania- Vengeance...
... Kelly.
Jeff Probst: Kelly, that's 6, that's enough. You need to bring me your torch.
Kelly just nods accepting his fate as Hershey and Fraser are shown giggling. Kelly then takes his torch and places it in the holder in front of Jeff Probst.
Jeff Probst: Kelly, the tribe has spoken.
Jeff then places the snuffer on top of Kelly's torch. As he takes it off, smoke can be seen coming out of Kelly's torch where his flame once was.
Jeff Probst: You will have a chance to get back in the game. Grab your torch, and head over to the Vengeance camp.
Kelly turns to his former tribe mates
Kelly: Good luck guys.
Kelly then takes his torch, leaves the tribal council area, and walks off into the night
Jeff Probst: Well, clearly early in the game, you guys are thinking of challenge strength first. We'll see if that pays off in the long run. Although you have attended tribal council, you will not yet receive flint until you win a challenge. Grab your torches, head back to camp. Good night.
| Tribal Council 2: Hobart | |
|---|---|
| Voted Against |
Voter |
 Kelly (8 votes) |
        Fraser, Hershey, Inge, K.C., Megan, Percy, Selina, & Vicktor |
Hershey (2 votes) |
 Gail & Kelly |
| VOTED OFF: Kelly Willett | |
Final Words[]
| “ | I'm pissed off that I was just voted out! I'm not mad at Libby, even though she's a lying little snake, I'm more mad that I left and Willy Wonka is still there. Oh well, his attitude is going to bite him in the ass sooner or later. It may be only day 3, but I can already tell that he can't win this game! Go Molly! Go Sheila! Go Cameron!! If I can't win this, I hope one of them do! | ” |
–Tamara Oakenwald | ||
| “ | I'm definitely not surprised that my tribe decided to do away with me. It's pretty much my fault that we lost the challenge today. For their sake though, I hope that Selina, Fraser, and Hershey get off their asses and pick up some of the slack so that they don't die. Although I have no faith in Hershey whatsoever! | ” |
–Kelly Willett | ||
Pyengana Voting Confessionals[]
| “ | Tamara, I’m really sorry to have to do this on the first vote. William just comes across as someone that would be loyal to me throughout the entire game and unfortunately, neither he or Libby is willing to vote Sheila out tonight. Good luck to you. | ” |
–Yoshi | ||
| “ | You my friend, are an ass****. That’s all I have to say. | ” |
–Sheila | ||
| “ | Tamara, I fully admit that William’s a jackass and I totally admire the way that you’ve been standing up for both Cameron and yourself the past few days. Unfortunately, William is not only good at puzzles, but he’s also shown to be fiercely loyal and those are assets I can certainly use in this game right now. Good luck on Vengeance | ” |
–Jocelyn | ||
| “ | Tamara, you do NOTHING for this tribe. I will not let a girl obsessed with purple and possibly influenced by Satan run this game. Good bye and good riddance! | ” |
–William | ||
| “ | William, if you think I’m going to sit idly by and just let myself be on the bottom of your alliance, you’ve got another thing coming. Besides, I think I’m going to enjoy the beautiful sight of your torch getting snuffed. | ” |
–Molly | ||
| “ | Tamara, I think you’re an amazing young lady. Unfortunately, I have to go with the majority on this one. Take care, and good luck on Vengeance. | ” |
–Lamont | ||
| “ | I’m really sorry Tamara. Believe me, I tried to talk some sense into Libby, but she just wouldn’t listen. As of this moment, I appear to be stuck with her in this game, so please don’t take this personally. Good luck to you. | ” |
–Phoenix | ||
| “ | Good-bye ass****! I pray to God you don’t come back! | ” |
–Cameron | ||
| “ | I am sick and tired of your judgmental ass Willy Wonka! Honestly, I don't give a s*** if you like that nickname or not because clearly you don't give enough of a s*** to get to know Cameron and I before placing unfair judgment on us. Since it's clearly you or me tonight, good bye Willy Wonka, I wish you all the worst! | ” |
–Tamara | ||
| “ | Sorry girl, I may not like William either, but I just can’t justify voting someone out that I know I can beat in the end. I hope you understand. | ” |
–Libby | ||
Hobart Voting Confessionals[]
| “ | I thought chocolate was supposed to be sweet. After living with you for three terrible days though, it’s clear that either chocolate isn’t sweet at all, or you’re just long past your expiration date. | ” |
–Gail | ||
| “ | Sorry Kelly, this is nothing against you, it’s just about keeping the tribe strong for future challenges. Take care. | ” |
–Vicktor | ||
| “ | Sorry bro, I can’t stand Hershey, but majority rules. | ” |
–Percy | ||
| “ | I love having you around camp, Kelly. You remind me so much of my Grandfather and I wish I could get to know you better. I’m only casting this vote for you because I’m in an alliance with Hershey. Hope you understand. I’m going to miss you. | ” |
–Megan | ||
| “ | And so continues the long-standing tradition of old women leaving the game early… well, old people with female names, that is. | ” |
–Fraser | ||
| “ | Out here you've proven to be nothing but a lazy, annoying, horny little girl. You're "Best Before Date" is clearly long gone and so I hope it's you tonight and not me. | ” |
–Kelly | ||
| “ | Never underestimate someone as sweet as Hershey's chocolate. | ” |
–Hershey | ||
| “ | Sorry Kelly, I can’t afford to betray someone THIS early in the game. Take care of yourself and good luck trying to tame the crazy purple girl. | ” |
–Selina | ||
| “ | Sorry Kelly, just following the majority. | ” |
–Inge | ||
| “ | Hershey may be a stupid, rude, lazy, immature, horny, selfish, spoiled, bratty, careless, pretentious, superficial, annoying, twat. But keeping her over you is the best thing for both this tribe and my game at this point. See ya’ on the flip side. | ” |
–K.C. | ||
Next Time on Survivor[]
Tamara and Kelly bond on Vengeance
We're the modern-day Outcasts, and we're ready to fight!
Cameron feels betrayed by Libby.
What happened to "Young people to the end?!"
And
Gail sees that she's on the outs and fights to get back in the game.
There's no chance in Hell that I'll let Chocolate Bar and Sassy Pants run this game!
Polls[]
Still in the Running[]
| Hobart | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fraser |
Gail |
Hershey |
Inge |
K.C. |
Kelly |
Megan |
Percy |
Selina |
Vicktor |
| Pyengana | |||||||||
Cameron |
Jocelyn |
Lamont |
Libby |
Molly |
Phoenix |
Sheila |
Tamara |
William |
Yoshi |